Matches in Nanopublications for { <http://purl.org/np/RAFkOk9kJeqhdud9oay7g7cPVRePs-Otdc2X38Zl6x0YQ#comment-13> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 7 of
7
with 100 items per page.
- comment-13 type ContentComment assertion.
- comment-13 type ReviewComment assertion.
- comment-13 type NegativeComment assertion.
- comment-13 type ActionNeededComment assertion.
- comment-13 hasCommentText "The representation of generated statements should be better clarified. In fact, in Section 2 they authors provide an example that does not reflect the semantics provided by the example in Section 9 (page 10). Namely, in the first example the authors state that, from the sentence "In Euro 1992, Germany reached the final, but lost 0-2 to Denmark", the pipeline generates: * a new statement "Germany defeat Denmark" where defeat is the frame * a set of facts about the new property by using FEs. Instead, in the second example, for the same sentence, the pipeline generates * a new statement ":Germany defeat :Defeat01" * a set of facts about the object :Defeat01 The semantics of the first example leds to extensional issues when adding new facts to a property/frame. This issues seem to be resolved by the second example. However, the statement is completely different as no explicit binary relation is generated between Germany and Denmark. Rather, a more coherent (with respect to first example) and correct formalisation could be the following: :Germany :defeat_01 :Denmark . :defeat_01 rdfs:subPropertyOf :defeat . :defeat_01 :winner :Denmark ; :loser :Germany ; :competition :Euro_1992 ; :score "0-2" ." assertion.
- comment-13 hasImpact "3" assertion.
- comment-13 refersTo section assertion.